Click our Site Map link at the top of the page to navigate the features of the site.

NFLFreaks 2005 Fantasy Football Sleepers

NFLFreaks Staff - August 25, 2005


Every Freak defines it a little bit differently, so In case you are as little unsure of what a sleeper is, it's a player who will deliver good value, but will be available much later in the draft than that value would dictate.  Therefore in theory you could find a top 15 receiver lying around after the first 30 receivers have been taken.

The key to successfully capitalizing on sleepers is to select them as late as possible in the draft, but be aware that the other teams will be looking for them too!  Value selections are the key to building good depth on a fantasy team, so check out who the Freaks think are flying under the radar in 2005.


Hindsight


Quarterback Sleepers

A recycled talent, a career backup and an aging veteran...those are my sleepers.  All will be chosen as fantasy backups at best and should be available in the back half of your draft.

Brian Griese (Tampa Bay Buccaneers)

Griese is going into his 8th year in the league, and unlike most positions quarterbacks get better when they reach their late 20's / early 30's.  After a number of so-so fantasy years in Denver and a brief stint in Miami, Brian was re-signed by Tampa Bay in the off-season and is clearly the number one on the depth chart.  In 2004 he played in 11 games (starting in 10), and finished with 2,632 yards and 20 touchdowns.  If you equate that out to a full season, that's about 4,000 yards and 30 scores which would place him among the fantasy elite. 

On the negative side his inconsistency worries me a little as he had 5 games where he threw for less than 200 yards.  This will be his second year in the offense though, which should help him iron out his game.  I also like the weapons around him and his strength of schedule (9th easiest), which features only three games against teams with top 10 passing defenses (Miami, Buffalo and Washington) and four cushy match-ups against Minnesota, Green Bay and New Orleans (twice).

Billy Volek (Tennessee Titans)

Who?  No I didn't mistype Michael Vick, this guy is the backup in Tennessee and for the record I have never before recommended drafting a number two QB. 

In 2004 Volek finally got his chance to shine, and many savvy fantasy owners rode him to a championship down the stretch (Remember that 492 yard, 4 touchdown game against the Raiders in week 15?).  In 10 games (8 starts) Volek racked up 2,486 yards and 19 touchdowns (18 in the air).  Do the math on that one and it translates loosely into 5,000 yards and 38 touchdowns over a 16 game schedule.  Those kinds of numbers put him well past first round selections like Manning and Culpepper.

Of course Volek won't play 16 games this year.  Steve McNair is still the starter and he has made a career out of playing hurt.  It caught up with him in 2004 though, and like the saying goes, he isn't getting any younger.  The other knock on Volek is the loss of Derrick Mason, the previous number one receiver in Tennessee.  Although his favorite target Drew Bennett returns, Bennett will now be the number one guy and how well the two of them will perform without Mason taking the heat is anyone's guess.

The point is that this guy is a fantasy gold mine, and he will be available in the final rounds of your draft.  Rather than taking a 7th receiver or a second kicker, take a flyer on Billy, bury him on your roster and wait until McNair's inevitable injury.

Kurt Warner (Arizona Cardinals)

Ahhh...how the mighty have fallen.  The once dominant fantasy quarterback is not even considered by many a viable fantasy backup for 2005.  Fools.

Yes Warner has had some very poor fantasy seasons, he has had less touchdowns (10) than interceptions (16) over the previous 3 years.  However, I think that this was due to a mixture of injuries and of course playing in Tom Coughlin's Giants offense (shudder).

His move to sunny Arizona should be the cure for what has ailed him however.  Denny Green has successfully recycled aging quarterbacks time and time again (Randall Cunningham. Jeff George, Brad Johnson, etc.) and you would be a fool not to trust his judgment on this one as well. Add to that the young talent around him (Fitzgerald, Boldin. Arrington/Shipp) and he is in a good position to rack up solid fantasy numbers.

Don't expect a return to his two MVP years in terms of final stats, but Warner will be an inexpensive steal as your fantasy backup.

Running Back Sleepers

These guys aren't names you have never heard of, but they are going well after the first 20 backs have been taken in drafts that I have seen.  As all three could finish in the top 20 these are low-risk / high-reward players.

Mewelde Moore (Minnesota Vikings)

First off, let's get past the rumors that I only picked him as a sleeper because I like saying "Mewelde".  If this was all about my well documented fondness for players with weird names I would have picked the Vikings' rookie Ciatrick Fason (How sweet is that?).

Now the first thing that has to be said is that Moore only has real value if Michael Bennett gets hurt.  Bennett is the man in Minnesota, and they really want him to (finally) stay healthy and get 15-20 touches per game.  However, his injury history is against him; he only played in 8 games in 2003 and 11 in 2004.

In Mewelde's rookie campaign he had limited playing time yet he got on the field enough to show his talent.  He averaged 5.8 yards per carry in 65 attempts, and he caught 27 balls for 238 additional yards.  This illustrates the kind of upside he could bring if Bennett goes down.

The knock on him, besides being second string, is that Vikings coach Mike Tice shuffles running backs so often it is hard to imagine him taking a "stick with one guy" approach.  Veteran Moe Williams and rookie Ciatrick Fason will be in the mix and that makes me a little nervous.

In the final analysis you should pick up Mewelde if A.) You own Michael Bennett, or B.) If the Michael Bennett owner waits too long and you can get him in the mid-rounds of your draft. (Can you say "Trade Bait"?)

DeShaun Foster (Carolina Panthers)

This guy is not an unknown quantity, yet he is tragically undervalued by the fantasy world.  The knock on him is his injury history.  After a stellar career at UCLA, he entered the league as the number two guy in Carolina behind Stephen Davis.  He showed real flashes of both speed and power, particularly in the 2003 playoffs as the Panthers made their Super Bowl run.

In 2004 he was highly touted entering the season but he suffered a broken collar bone, his second season-ending injury. (Knee surgery in 2002)  With a total of only five starts in three years, he hardly has a proven track record, but I think that the stars will align for him in 2005.

Stephen Davis is coming off of microfracture knee surgery, and his work in camp has been sparing at best.  The other competition comes from the rookie Eric Shelton, a big back (6-1, 246 lbs.) with speed and Nick Goings, who performed well in 2004 (1,217 yards and 7 touchdowns combined) but appears to be hated by the Carolina coaching staff.

So how do I pick a guy who has problems staying healthy and plenty of competition in town as a sleeper?  Let's just say that I have a feeling on this one.  Considering that he was the 24th running back taken in our mock draft, he's well worth the pick.

Ricky Williams (Miami Dolphins)

The biggest joke in fantasy football is the spin being put on Ricky Williams.  Just watch all of the talking heads going on about his lack of commitment, his lack of goals for the season, his year off, his low playing weight and the impacts to his playing time based upon his 4 game suspension.

What none of them are talking about are the real questions.

1.  Are the Dolphins really finished with Ricky or do they still see him as the franchise back?

2.  How much faith can they put in an untested rookie back who didn't even handle the whole load in college?

3.  If Miami is looking to trade him, can they afford not to let him showcase his talents on the field?

Obviously the worst case scenario is that while Ricky serves out his suspension, Ronnie Brown wows the coaches and his team with three or four great performances, most of which result in wins. When Ricky comes back he is an afterthought and he only sees the field to spell Brown.

However, Miami plays three of its first four games against teams with top 10 rushing defenses (Jets, Panthers and Bills), they have a new offensive coordinator and an unsettled quarterback situation.  That will likely to lead to a slow start offensively which will play to Williams' advantage.  With a 2-2 or 1-3 start, the team and their fans will be looking for a change.

The point is that Ricky still has the tools to be an elite back, what he needs is the opportunity.  He should get that opportunity in 2005, and although he won't reach his 2002 numbers (2,216 yards combined and 17 touchdowns) even half that production is a good fantasy season.  Considering the dirt-cheap price for Williams this year (he was drafted in the 10th round in our mock draft!) he is probably the best bargain I have ever seen.

Wide Receiver Sleepers

I would like to title this section "Have You Forgotten?"  It seems that most of the fantasy world has, all of these guys are waaaay undervalued considering the upside they could bring.

Anquan Boldin (Arizona Cardinals)

In 2003 Anquan Boldin was the offensive rookie of the year and he finished third in fantasy scoring among all wide receivers with 1,377 yards and 8 touchdowns.  Last year he missed the first six games after undergoing arthroscopic knee surgery, and he didn't hit his stride until the end of the season.

In 2005 he is healthy, he has a real quarterback in Kurt Warner, a legitimate threat (Larry Fitzgerald) on the other side to take the pressure off of him and Denny Green's proven offensive system in place.

For a guy who finished third as a rookie, I see big things for him as he enters his third year which is known as the breakout year for young receivers.

Chris Chambers (Miami Dolphins)

This one falls into my "Gut Check" category as well.  Chambers is a really talented player who has been cursed with a series of poor quarterbacks.  This season will mark his 4th year as a full-time starter, and this should be the year he finally gets 1,000 yards receiving.  (His best output previously was in 2003 where he put up 963 yards and 11 touchdowns.)  There are several factors why he makes my sleeper list, so here goes...

I like Scott Linehan.  He is the new offensive coordinator in Miami after an extremely successful stint in Minnesota.  He likes to pass the ball a lot if you hadn't noticed.

I like Gus Frerotte. (Yeah, I said it.)  He should win the job over A.J. Feeley, and I think that he has the ability to deliver the big play.  A bonus, Frerotte has already worked with Linehan in Minnesota and knows the offensive scheme.

I like the Miami running game.  With both Ronnie Brown and Ricky Williams keeping defenses honest, opportunities should abound for the passing game.

Chambers probably won't even be among the top 20 receivers selected on draft day, so he'll be a great number 2 or 3 pickup for your team.

Marcus Robinson (Minnesota Vikings)

This guy falls into my "You're Reaching" category, but he is the epitome of a sleeper.  In our mock draft I picked him up with the 200th pick.  Yes, that's right, he went dead last in the draft.  By no means however does that make him a "Mr. Irrelevant".

Last season Robinsoin was primarily the number three receiver in Minnesota, although he did have seven starts in the earlier part of the season.  He finished with 657 yards and 8 touchdowns which was pretty good for a fantasy reserve.

This year Marcus has locked down the number two receiver slot for the Vikings, and with Randy Moss out of town there will be a lot of catches to spread around.  If he doesn't lose his position to free agent pickup Travis Taylor or to rookie Troy Williamson, he could easily have 1,000 yards and double-digit touchdowns.


StingRay



Quarterback - Joey Harrington (Detroit Lions)

Does anyone else think that Joey Harrington is getting judged too harshly for his performance the last couple of seasons? The Lions acquired 35 year old Jeff Garcia and everyone is ready to anoint him the starter in Detroit. Is it Harrington’s fault that Charles Rogers has been injured the past two years?  Roy Williams was a fabulous rookie but he was still a rookie and he too was injured for part of the year and Harrington still had his best season as a pro, throwing for 19 touchdowns and 12 interceptions. (The first time in his career he threw more touchdowns then interceptions.) His completion percentage and passer rating improved as well.

If Harrington continues to progress what kind of year will he have if Charles Rogers is healthy?  Roy Williams is a stud and the Lions drafted Mike Williams who might have been the number one overall pick if he didn’t have to sit out a season when he tried to jump to the NFL. The Lions also acquired former Colts tight end Marcus Pollard and they have a very good back in Kevin Jones. Harrington should be able to throw 25 to 26 touchdowns in this offense. I think he’s this year’s Drew Brees.


Running Back - Steven Jackson (St. Louis Rams)

Steven Jackson has taken over for Marshall Faulk as the number one back in St. Louis and he’s in for a big year. Have you seen the St. Louis Rams schedule? Besides facing the 49ers, Cardinals, and Seahawks twice the Rams have games against the Colts, Giants, Texans, Saints, Titans and Vikings. With those matchups I could probably score 7 or 8 touchdowns. (smile)

As a rookie Steven Jackson averaged 5.0 yards per carry and added some toughness to the Rams running game. Now, that he is the starter look for Jackson to put up numbers worthy of a number one running back. He is not regarded that high in most of the drafts that I have seen so he is a good bargain back on draft day who has tremendous upside. Don’t you sleep on Steven Jackson.

Wide Receivers - Donald Driver (Green Bay Packers)

In 2002 Donald Driver had a breakout season when he caught 70 passes for 1,064 yards and 9 touchdowns. Expectations were high for Driver in 2003 but after he suffered a neck injury early in the year he was not the same player that we saw in 2002.

Last season when Javon Walker was dominating the fantasy world Driver quietly had an impressive season. He caught 84 passes for 1,208 yards and 9 touchdowns. When people talk about top fantasy receivers Donald Driver’s name seems to be left out of the discussion. Driver is a great number two receiver who can post numbers that are as good as a number one receiver. Driver can be picked up in the 6th or 7th round of most fantasy drafts.

 


The Sandman


I like to break down the keepers into three categories;

(1) Sleeper, someone who would normally be drafted but would serve on most fantasy teams as a backup, but this year he is worth starting every week. An example from last year would be Carson Palmer.

(2) Deep Sleeper, someone who is generally known but this is the year that they step up or bounce back. Rookies also fall into this category but only someone who was drafted outside the first round. An example of this last year would be Javon Walker or Drew Brees.

(3) Rip Van Winkle, an unknown player or a backup that by the end of the season everyone will wish that they had them on their team. An example from last year would be Antonio Gates.


Quarterback Sleepers


Sleeper – Jake Delhomme (Carolina Panthers)

It is amazing to me that Delhomme continues to fly under the radar in most leagues but he always does. In each of the last two seasons he has passed for 20 TD’s and 3,000+ yards. I know that he lost Muhsin Muhammad but Steve Smith (1,100 yards and 7 touchdowns in 2003) is coming back so Delhomme really isn’t losing anything. Last year he had a career year, without a running game. Stephen Davis and DeShaun Foster will both be ready week 1 this year so defenses will bite on the play-action-pass.

Deep Sleeper – Eli Manning (New York Giants)

The former No.1 overall pick showed tremendous improvement over the last three weeks of 2004. He had 5 touchdown passes and two games in which his passer rating was over 100. Keep in mind that his two receivers didn’t catch a touchdown pass all year. The Giants went out and signed Plaixco Burress so that won’t happen this year. Also, Amani Toomer battled a hamstring injury all season and he has stated that he is 100% healthy. Tiki Barber can catch the ball out of the backfield and Jeremey Shockey is nice target in the red-zone.

Rip Van Winkle – Jeff Garcia (Detroit Lions)

The best thing to happen to Garcia was being cut by the Browns. He took the backup job in Detroit and was reunited with his former coach in San Francisco, Steve Mariucci. Mariucci knows what Garcia can do in the west coast offense so when Joey Harrington starts slowly, Garcia will take over. I anticipate this happening on or before week 4. Garcia has a solid running game with Kevin Jones, and three former first round wide receiver selections in Charles Rogers, Roy Williams and Mike Williams. This is same formula that worked for Mariucci and Garcia in San Francisco.


Running Back Sleepers

Sleeper – Julius Jones (Dallas Cowboys)

It is amazing what Bill Parcells can do for a running back's career. First he drafted and developed Curtis Martin into an all-pro running back and now he has a new project. Jones, who missed 7 games with a shoulder injury, had 100+ total yards in 4 of the last 7 games. He also had 7 touchdowns over that time span. I love running backs that finish the previous season strong and Jones should get the ball 30 times a game in 2005. One more nugget, he was third in the NFL last year in rushing yards per game.

Deep Sleeper – J.J. Arrington (Arizona Cardinals)

For the first time in years the Cardinals go into training camp knowing who their week 1 starter will be. Arrington is a smallish back who can hit the hole quick (4.46 seconds in the 40-yard dash.) The bonus that you get with Arrington is that he can catch the ball out of the backfield. Arizona averaged over 100 yards rushing per game last year and they were 8th in the league in rushing touchdowns. Their problem has been that their starter never makes it through a full season.

Rip Van Winkle – Frank Gore (San Francisco 49ers)

Gore, a third round draft pick from the University of Miami, goes into the season as the backup to Kevan Barlow, but some people in the organization think that he is a better back. Gore had a major knee surgery last year and that is why he wasn’t drafted until the third round. The 49ers are going to start a questionable quarterback so they will run the ball often. Another reason why I like Gore is that Barlow lost his starting job to Maurice Hicks last year so any slip up and the 49ers will give Gore a shot.


NFLFreaks Home | Game Prep | Game Focus | Player Performance Predictions | Start-Bench List | The Line 

 Player News | Draft Central | Fantasy Features | Freak Of the Week | Hall of Shame | Ask the Freaks | NFL Statistics

 NFL Standings | NFL Schedule |  Fantasy Resources | NFL Team Links | Local Newspapers | Fantasy Site Links


We want to publish the best, most complete and authoritative site on the internet.  What do you want to see?  Email us at Our Users Make the Call to get your thoughts, comments and suggestions about the site.

Are you getting strange error messages?  Are any of the java controls not displaying (i.e. big, gray boxes appearing)?  Are you having trouble with pages loading slowly or pages not displaying at all?  Whatever trouble you may be having, we want to know about it.  For problems or questions regarding this web site please contact NFLFreaks Support.

NFLFreaks.com is not in any way affiliated with, endorsed or licensed by the National Football League (NFL), any NFL team or any National Football League Players Association (NFLPA) members.           

© Copyright 1998-2005 NFLFreaks.com. All rights reserved.