Start-Bench List - Quarterbacks - Week 17


This is our weekly feature where we give you our take on the players who you should give special consideration to when you are choosing your starters.

Only players that have particularly good or bad match-ups this week are listed. All unlisted players are considered to be in an average scoring situation.  For a more complete listing of fantasy football player forecasts, check out our Player Performance Projections and Game Focus Predictions features.

If you have any problems with this page please email us at Start-Bench List Support.

 

Quarterbacks | Running Backs | Wide Receivers | Tight Ends


Sure Thing

Strong Starter

Gut Check

Forget About It

 

Sure Thing - Players you must start on your team

 

Kurt Warner - vs St.Louis

Sure Thing StingRay: (A-) Warner just won me two championships so stick with him. He will post close to 300 yards and at least 2 touchdown passes.

Tom Brady - at New York Giants

Sure Thing CrunchTime: (A-) With the bye next week Brady will get at least 3 quarters of work and will be well worth starting as they try and wrap up the perfect regular season. The Giants will ease off the effort once this game gets even mildly out of hand, the Patriots will not.

Strong Starter - Players you should give strong consideration to starting

 

Derek Anderson - vs. San Francisco

Strong Starter Smokin' Joe: (B+) Anderson is a very good number one this week against the 26th ranked 49ers passing defense.

Marc Bulger - at Arizona

Strong Starter StingRay: (B+) Bulger will do damage to the Cardinals 20th ranked passing defense.

Sage Rosenfels - vs. Jacksonville

Strong Starter Smokin' Joe: (B+) The Jaguars are 19th against the pass and will not want to get any of their starting defenders hurt before the playoffs so I would expect Rosenfels to put up above average numbers.

Chris Redman - vs. Seattle

Strong Starter CrunchTime: (B) In three of his four starts he's posted at least 20 points and been worth starting. This week he faces the 20th ranked pass defense of Seattle and looks to be targeting another 20 point outing. This week is no different than any other for the Falcons as they've been out of the hunt for quite some time. This game means a lot more to them than it does NFC's #3 seed.

Cleo Lemon - vs. Cincinnati

Strong Starter CrunchTime: (B) Lemon is not usually a stud scorer, but you have to like his match up this week as all the Dolphins continue their early auditions for Parcells. The Bengals give up around 230 yards and almost 2 scores each week to opponents' passing attacks. That's good enough to make Lemon a worth while option in the most strange of fantasy weeks.

Donovan McNabb - vs. Buffalo

Strong Starter Smokin' Joe: (B) McNabb should be able to post very good numbers against the 28th ranked Bills passing defense.

Carson Palmer - at Miami

Strong Starter CrunchTime: (B-) With four straight poor outings, including a missed opportunity against Cleveland, Palmer has continued to let owners down. This week that may continue, but I do like his chances of getting a couple touchdown tosses against a team that ranks 25th in the league in passing touchdowns against.

Jay Cutler - vs Minnesota

Strong Starter StingRay: (B-) You can't run on Minnesota so Cutler will throw plenty in this game.

Matt Hasselbeck - at Atlanta

Strong Starter CrunchTime: (B-) Look for Hasselbeck to at least play a half, and potentially more. Even with just a half of play he's a decent option against the Falcons' rocky ship. I expect him to post around 180 yards and 1 – 2 scores. And yes, that's more than I expect from many this week.

Shaun Hill - at Cleveland

Strong Starter Smokin' Joe: (B-) The Browns are 29th against the pass so Hill should have another good game this Sunday. He threw 3 touchdowns last week against the Bucs.

Todd Collins - vs. Dallas

Strong Starter CrunchTime: (B-) With all the teams who are just waiting for next week, I like the teams that have something to play for. Collins has posted solid outings in two of his three weeks and is facing a Dallas team that's sitting pretty. He isn't likely to put up any astounding numbers, but this week he's an above average option.

Gut Check - Players you should only consider starting if you don't have a better option

 

Matt Moore - at Tampa Bay

Gut Check CrunchTime: (C+) He hasn't proven himself yet, but it will be like pre-season for him this week against most of the Tampa second stringers. That makes him an interesting choice for all you owners whose normal starters aren't going to play much this week.

Vince Young - at Indianapolis

Gut Check CrunchTime: (C+) Young has been a pretty big disappointment but has the most to play for this weekend. Normally the Colts are a horrid match up (1st against the pass), but this week they'll likely be resting some key players and Young could capitalize. After all, their playoffs start this week.

Drew Brees - at Chicago

Gut Check Smokin' Joe: (C) The Bears were able to shut down the Packers at home last week so I would not expect great numbers from Brees this week.

Jon Kitna - at Green Bay

Gut Check Smokin' Joe: (C) Kitna is hot and cold and he is facing an above average Packers pass defense so do not be surprised if he struggles again this week.

Philip Rivers - at Oakland

Gut Check StingRay: (C) I hated watching Rivers trash talk Monday night since he isn't very good. The Raiders will give him trouble on Sunday.

Tony Romo - at Washington

Gut Check CrunchTime: (C) It's unclear how much of Romo we should expect to see this week. We know we won't see any Owens and that Glenn should make an appearance, but beyond that he's a big gamble given that NFC home field advantage is all locked up.

Brett Favre - vs. Detroit

Gut Check Smokin' Joe: (C-) The Packer starters are only expected to play the first half. You should look elsewhere.

Eli Manning - vs. New England

Gut Check CrunchTime: (C-) He's had some bad conditions of late, but he's had even worse performances. With only 2 passing touchdowns in the last 3 games you must have a better option. Add to that the possibility that Plaxico sits all or a good portion of the game and he's a rough option.

Jeff Garcia / Luke McCown - vs. Carolina

Gut Check CrunchTime: (C-) We can be sure they'll split time, it's just not entirely clear to what extent. Plus, I'm not sure McCown is someone you want starting for you against the 13th ranked pass defense in the league.

Kyle Orton - vs. New Orleans

Gut Check Smokin' Joe: (C-) The Saints are 30th against the pass so if you need an emergency starter this week Orton should post good numbers.

Peyton Manning - vs. Tennessee

Gut Check CrunchTime: (C-) He's a big risk this week, and a great example of why fantasy should end prior to week 17. Manning is only likely to play extended time if Harrison goes and they decide to work on their timing. Either way, I'm not expecting to see him on the field much, and his backup wouldn't be a good option against a Titans team fighting for their playoff lives.

Trent Edwards - at Philadelphia

Gut Check Smokin' Joe: (C-) Edwards has been okay, but I think the Eagles defense will be able to pressure and confuse him. Start someone else.

Forget About It - Players you shouldn't even think about starting

 

Kellen Clemens - vs Kansas City

Forget About It StingRay: (D+) Pennington will be sent back to the bench this week for Clemens. The Chiefs are ranked 13th against the pass.

Troy Smith - vs. Pittsburgh

Forget About It Smokin' Joe: (D+) Smith did not exactly light up the scoreboard last week but he will start for Boller again this week. The Steelers are not a good match up for rookie quarterbacks.

David Garrard - at Houston

Forget About It Smokin' Joe: (D) Garrard will probably not play more then a half so you can't trust any Jaguars.

Tarvaris Jackson - at Denver

Forget About It StingRay: (D-) He may run one in but I don't see him throwing any touchdowns this week.

Ben Roethlisberger - at Baltimore

Forget About It Smokin' Joe: (F) Roethlisberger is probably not going to play this weekend. The Steelers are looking to get him healthy for the playoffs. I would not start Charlie Batch in his place.

Brodie Croyle - at New York Jets

Forget About It StingRay: (F ) Questionable for this week and he's not very good.

JaMarcus Russell - vs San Diego

Forget About It StingRay: (F) The San Diego defense is playing extremely well and the rookie has a lot to learn.

Quarterbacks | Running Backs | Wide Receivers | Tight Ends


 

 

 

 

 

 

News and Analysis:  Player News / Ask the Freaks / Freak of the Week / Hall of Shame

Lineup Tools: Match-Up Analysis Tool / Start-Bench List / Player Performance Projections / Game Focus

NFL Information: Fantasy Stats / NFL Standings / 2006 NFL Schedule / The Line

Fantasy Resources: NFL Team Links / Local Newspapers / Fantasy Football Site Links / ESPN Injuries

Draft Central: Index / Pre-Season Cheat Sheets / Mock Draft / Sleepers / Strength of Schedule Rankings

NFLFreaks Site: Site Map / Testimonials

As always, NFLFreaks.com is your complete source for free fantasy football news, articles, advice, player rankings and statistics. Everything you'll need to dominate your league you will find right here on one site. Keep coming back because our content is constantly updated, bringing you the best in expertise, writing and entertainment.

We want to publish the best, most complete and authoritative site on the internet. What do you want to see? Email us at Our Users Make the Call to get your thoughts, comments and suggestions about the site.

Are you getting strange error messages? Are any of the java controls not displaying (i.e. big, gray boxes appearing)? Are you having trouble with pages loading slowly or pages not displaying at all? Whatever trouble you may be having, we want to know about it. For problems or questions regarding this web site please contact NFLFreaks.com Support.

NFLFreaks.com.com is not in any way affiliated with, endorsed or licensed by the National Football League (NFL), any NFL team or any National Football League Players Association (NFLPA) members.

© Copyright 1998-2006 NFLFreaks.com. All rights reserved.